Litigation · Orders and procedural record

West Bengal OBC Litigation Timeline

This tracker separates what an order actually records from later policy action. It is a research index, not legal advice; case status must be checked with the relevant court before reliance.

134Archived source PDFs
66Classes in Notification 945
7%Reservation in the May 2026 notice
5Evidence gaps tracked
Reviewed 4 November 2026. The State’s specified SLPs were withdrawn on 14 July. The 12 August certificate-validity judgment is followed by fresh Supreme Court proceedings on 1 October: appointments must abide by the outcome and carry that condition in appointment letters. That order does not restore 17% reservation or grant a general stay. It directs listing on 23 November 2026; verify the eventual cause list. July withdrawal · August judgment · October order
49 Timeline records
46 Judgments and orders
3 Reports and party filings

Cases at a glance

Proceedings and where they stand

Each card groups the orders of one proceeding, with its case numbers, current position, linked court records and news coverage.

View these cases as a map →

Calcutta High CourtDecided · judgment stands

Amal Chandra Das v. State of West Bengal

WPO 60 of 2011 WPA 22145 of 2010 WPO 1160 of 2013 WPO 578 of 2012

The 22 May 2024 judgment struck down the OBC classification of 77 classes made from 2010 and the OBC certificates issued on that basis, while protecting people already appointed. The State's appeals against it were withdrawn on 14 July 2026.

1 court record · 2 news reports
  1. Calcutta High Court: connected OBC-list and reservation matters PDF

In the news

Supreme Court of IndiaState and Commission petitions withdrawn 14 Jul 2026

State of West Bengal v. Amal Chandra Das and connected appeals

SLP(C) 17751-17755 of 2024 SLP(C) 16936 of 2024 (Aatmadeep) SLP(C) 18926-18935 of 2024 SLP(C) 20849 of 2024 SLP(C) 29017-29021 of 2024 Diary 27287 of 2024

The State and the West Bengal Commission for Backward Classes appealed the 2024 judgment. On 5 August 2024 the Court issued notice and asked the State to explain the survey and consultation behind the 77 designations. In March 2025 the State said the Commission was redoing the exercise, and on 6 November 2025 the Court told the High Court not to go ahead with the hearing until further orders. On 14 July 2026 the State and Commission petitions were withdrawn; other aggrieved parties may still pursue their own challenges.

9 court records · 6 news reports
  1. Supreme Court: Aatmadeep’s SLP paper book PDF
  2. Supreme Court: notice on the State's appeals; State told to explain how the 77 classes were chosen PDF
  3. Supreme Court: SLP(C) 17751–17755 of 2024 PDF
  4. Supreme Court: hearing on the State appeals; detailed arguments fixed for January PDF
  5. Supreme Court: broader connected-appeal cluster listed for final hearing PDF
  6. Supreme Court: State says the Commission is redoing the OBC exercise; matter posted to July PDF
  7. Supreme Court: State appeals listed for 6 November 2025 PDF
  8. Supreme Court: High Court not to go ahead with the hearing until further orders PDF
  9. Supreme Court: State and Commission petitions dismissed as withdrawn PDF

In the news

Calcutta High CourtListed together, January 2025

Aatmadeep and Amal Chandra Das implementation PILs

WPA(P) 387 of 2024 WPA(P) 430 of 2024

PILs seeking implementation of the 2024 judgment were listed together on 21 January 2025. WPA(P) 430 of 2024 was later heard with the 2025 notification challenge.

3 court records
  1. Calcutta High Court: universities warned over admissions to struck-down classes PDF
  2. Calcutta High Court: no stay of the 2013 admissions Act; orders sent to all universities PDF
  3. Calcutta High Court: Aatmadeep PIL and Amal Chandra Das PIL listed together PDF
Calcutta High CourtHC stay on 2025 lists revived, Aug 2026

Challenge to the 2025 benchmark survey and OBC notifications

WPA(P) 111 of 2025 WPA(P) 119 of 2025 WPA(P) 132 of 2025 WPA(P) 430 of 2024

On 17 June 2025 the High Court stayed the State's new 2025 OBC list. The Supreme Court stayed that order on 28 July 2025 and in November 2025 told the High Court not to proceed. After the State withdrew its appeals in July 2026, the Division Bench recorded in August 2026 that the 2025 stay was revived.

3 court records · 5 news reports
  1. Calcutta High Court: interim directions on the Commission's benchmark survey PDF
  2. Calcutta High Court: challenge to the 2025 benchmark-survey process PDF
  3. Calcutta High Court: Shreyasi Dhang certificate-validity judgment PDF

In the news

Supreme Court of IndiaState petitions withdrawn 14 Jul 2026

State of West Bengal v. Purabi Das and connected matters

SLP(C) 17422 of 2025 SLP(C) 17528 of 2025 SLP(C) 17973-17974 of 2025 SLP(C) 26497 of 2025

The State challenged the High Court's 17 June 2025 stay. On 28 July 2025 the Supreme Court called that order prima facie erroneous and stayed it. Applications to vacate the stay were listed in March 2026, and the State's petitions were withdrawn on 14 July 2026.

4 court records · 6 news reports
  1. Supreme Court: later 2025 appeal record PDF
  2. Supreme Court: stay of the 17 June 2025 High Court order PDF
  3. Supreme Court: connected OBC SLPs listed with applications to vacate stay PDF
  4. Supreme Court: State and Commission petitions dismissed as withdrawn PDF

In the news

Calcutta High Court → Supreme CourtHC directions stayed by SC, Aug 2025

Supriya Mondal v. State of West Bengal (JEMAS PG and WBJEE admissions)

WPA 9132 of 2025 MAT 943 of 2025 MAT 955 of 2025 CPAN 1362 of 2025 CPAN 1365 of 2025 SC Diary 45526 and 45628 of 2025

On 21 May 2025 the High Court directed admissions to follow the 2024 judgment. On 7 August 2025 it opened contempt proceedings over JEMAS PG and ordered a fresh WBJEE 2025 merit list on the pre-2010 basis. On 22 August 2025 the Supreme Court stayed those directions, letting results follow the State's June 2025 list, and tagged the matters with SLP(C) 17422 of 2025.

5 court records · 4 news reports
  1. Calcutta High Court: WBJEE PG admission implementation order PDF
  2. Calcutta High Court: JEMAS PG appeals referred on the meaning of "already availed" PDF
  3. Calcutta High Court: JEMAS PG contempt proceedings PDF PDF
  4. Calcutta High Court: fresh WBJEE 2025 merit list ordered on the pre-2010 basis PDF PDF
  5. Supreme Court: interim stay in the JEMAS PG contempt appeal PDF

In the news

Calcutta High CourtDisposed with direction to CEO, Dec 2025

Arijit Bakshi: voided OBC certificates in the electoral roll revision

Case number not reported

A voter asked that OBC certificates struck down in 2024 not be accepted as documents in the Special Intensive Revision. The Court directed the Chief Electoral Officer to decide within a week, and the CEO then barred their use.

1 court record · 3 news reports
  1. Calcutta High Court: voided OBC certificates and the electoral roll revision PDF

In the news

Calcutta High CourtWPA 14695 withdrawn 8 Jul 2026

Bistriti Parveen and Yasin Chowdhury recruitment-category petitions

WPA 14695 of 2026 WPA 14698 of 2026

Candidates challenged category rules in recruitment after the 2026 reset. Interim orders on 1 July extended application-editing dates. WPA 14695 was withdrawn on 8 July with liberty to file afresh.

3 court records
  1. Calcutta High Court: recruitment-category challenges after the 2026 reset PDF PDF
  2. Calcutta High Court: Bistriti Parveen petition withdrawn PDF
  3. Calcutta High Court: Yasin Chowdhury's OBC-A application protected pending the Supreme Court PDF
Calcutta High CourtNot entertained 3 Jul 2026

Right and Justice Foundation v. State of West Bengal

WPA(P) 305 of 2026 WPA 15380 of 2026 (Mahamadul Hasan Gayen)

A PIL against the 18 May 2026 notifications (944, 945 and 946) was not entertained because the Supreme Court was already seized of the main issues. The petitioner later went to the Supreme Court (Diary 41300 of 2026). A single-judge challenge to the same notifications was dismissed on 7 July 2026 for the same reason.

3 court records
  1. Calcutta High Court: first hearing of the PIL against the 18 May 2026 notifications PDF
  2. Calcutta High Court: PIL challenging the 18 May 2026 notifications PDF
  3. Calcutta High Court: single-judge challenge to the 18 May 2026 notifications dismissed PDF
Calcutta High Court → Supreme CourtPending in SC · listed 23 Nov 2026

Shreyasi Dhang v. State of West Bengal, and the Supreme Court challenges

MAT 1320 of 2026 CAN 1 of 2026 SC Diary 50605 of 2026 (Aktarul Islam) SC Diary 41300 of 2026 (Right and Justice Foundation) SC Diary 54999 of 2026

On 12 August 2026 the High Court held that OBC certificates issued under the May–June 2025 notifications were void, and that candidates relying on them must be treated as general category. On 1 October 2026 the Supreme Court issued notice and kept appointments subject to the outcome, without a general stay. It directed listing on 23 November 2026.

Next listing

2 court records · 6 news reports
  1. Calcutta High Court: Shreyasi Dhang certificate-validity judgment PDF
  2. Supreme Court: fresh challenges; appointments subject to outcome PDF

In the news

Calcutta High CourtPetitions dismissed, Aug–Sep 2026

NEET-UG and SLST candidates' category claims

WPA 21501 of 2026 (Hasibur Rahaman Mondal) WPA 23207 of 2026 (Mehebuba Khatun) WPA 23209 of 2026 MAT 1374 of 2026 SLP(C) 31121 of 2026

NEET-UG 2026 candidates who sought to switch to EWS after results, and SLST 2025 candidates who sought OBC-A reserved status, both lost. The Court held that category must be valid on the application date and that the 2024 judgment was final before the SLST recruitment began. The Division Bench upheld the NEET-UG ruling on 18 August 2026, and the Supreme Court closed the challenge on 5 October 2026, saying the EWS benefit would be available next year.

4 court records · 2 news reports
  1. Calcutta High Court: NEET-UG 2026 candidates cannot switch to EWS after results PDF
  2. Calcutta High Court: Division Bench upholds the NEET-UG EWS ruling PDF
  3. Calcutta High Court: SLST 2025 candidates cannot claim the struck-down OBC-A category PDF
  4. Supreme Court: NEET-UG EWS claim closed; benefit available next year PDF

In the news

Calcutta High CourtPending · affidavits called

Candidate category petitions after the certificate judgment

WPA 29788 of 2026 (Nilanjona Kundu) WPA 30672 of 2026 (Abeda Khatoon) WPA 31572 of 2026 (Mohabul Islam) WPA 31497 of 2026 (Sambhu Charan Bera)

October 2026 petitions deal with candidates whose category changed after the August judgment: representations to update category, candidates from retained classes, and former OBC applicants seeking EWS status in primary-teacher recruitment. In WPA 31572 the State must file affidavits within three weeks after the Puja vacation. On 30 October 2026 the Court held that the 14 October category-update window does not allow fresh applications. On 5 November 2026 the Primary Education Board reopened OBC status declarations from 5 to 9 November (Memo 3747).

4 court records · 2 news reports
  1. Calcutta High Court: Nilanjona Kundu category-update representations PDF
  2. Calcutta High Court: Abeda Khatoon retained-class candidates PDF
  3. Calcutta High Court: category-update window is not a fresh application window PDF
  4. Calcutta High Court: Mohabul Islam OBC-to-EWS claim requires affidavits PDF

In the news

Calcutta High CourtPending · APOT 136 listed 13 Nov 2026

Recruitment after the 2026 list: EWS moves, selected candidates and the new roster

FMA 1002 of 2026 (Mir Mazharul Islam) RVW 239 and 241 of 2026 (Arindam Saha) WPA 26656 of 2026 (Aslam Hossain) APOT 136 of 2026 (Shamim Akhtar) WPA 28984 of 2026 (Srikanta Chakraborty)

Cases on how ongoing recruitments handle candidates whose OBC status fell away. SLST candidates may be considered as EWS after verification (review refused); candidates already selected as OBC-A are outside the 7 August 2026 notification; candidates dropped from the list may compete as EWS in police recruitment. Whether the new roster can apply midway through a selection is pending before the Chief Justice's Bench.

Next listing

6 court records
  1. Calcutta High Court: SLST EWS appeal; School Service Commission asked about the BCW letter of 10 August 2026 PDF
  2. Calcutta High Court: SLST candidates to be considered as EWS after verification PDF
  3. Calcutta High Court: review of the SLST EWS judgment refused PDF
  4. Calcutta High Court: already-selected OBC-A candidates outside the 7 August 2026 notification PDF
  5. Calcutta High Court: new OBC roster in a selection already underway questioned PDF
  6. Calcutta High Court: candidates dropped from the OBC list may compete as EWS in police recruitment PDF
Calcutta High CourtPending; affidavits ordered 22 Jul 2026

Mijanul Kabir v. State of West Bengal

WPA(P) 319 of 2026

A second PIL against the 18 May 2026 notifications, filed days before the first one was turned away. It asks for Notifications 944 and 945 and Letter 946 to be quashed and for the 2025 notifications to be restored for the 74 affected communities. Unlike the first PIL it was not dismissed: on 22 July 2026 the Court called for affidavits and left open whether the PIL is maintainable.

2 court records
  1. Calcutta High Court: second PIL against the 18 May 2026 notifications; State asked to appear PDF
  2. Calcutta High Court: Mijanul Kabir PIL to be decided on affidavits; maintainability left open PDF
Calcutta High CourtMemo stayed 18 Aug 2026; pending

Dr. Md. Adil Hossain v. State of West Bengal (re-verification of caste certificates)

WPA(P) 275 of 2026 WPA(P) 300 of 2026 (CPI(ML) Liberation)

Two PILs against the BCW Department's memo of 14 May 2026, which told Sub-Divisional Officers to re-verify every SC, ST and OBC certificate issued since 2011 and linked the check to names deleted from the voter list. On 18 August 2026 the Court stayed the memo until the PILs are decided, while leaving officers free to act in individual cases under the 1994 Act and 1995 Rules. The Department sent the stay to all District Magistrates on 21 August 2026.

1 court record
  1. Calcutta High Court: re-verification of all caste certificates since 2011 stayed PDF
Employee-protection argument note: user-supplied grounds and precedent links for bona fide employees appointed on government-issued OBC certificates are included after the timeline. Open the legal-principles note.

Court records and updates

  1. Calcutta High Court: connected OBC-list and reservation matters

    WPO 60 of 2011 and connected matters, including WPA 22145 of 2010, WPO 1160 of 2013 and WPO 578 of 2012. The judgment is the legal turning point cited by the later 2025 and 2026 notifications. It should be read directly for the operative directions and the exact scope of the findings.

  2. Supreme Court: Aatmadeep’s SLP paper book

    SLP(C) 16936/2024, Aatmadeep v. State of West Bengal & Ors. The paper book states that it arises from the 22 May 2024 High Court judgment in WPA 8844/2020. It is a party filing, not an order of the Court.

  3. Supreme Court: notice on the State's appeals; State told to explain how the 77 classes were chosen

    A bench of the Chief Justice, J.B. Pardiwala and Manoj Misra JJ. condoned the delay and issued notice on the State's appeal against the 22 May 2024 judgment and on its stay application. The State was told to file an affidavit explaining what survey, if any, it carried out before the 77 communities were designated OBCs, on both social and educational backwardness and representation in State services; whether the Backward Classes Commission was consulted, especially on the 37 communities discussed at the hearing; and whether the Commission was consulted on the OBC-A/OBC-B sub-classification. The Commission was moved from petitioner to respondent, the NCBC could be added as a party, and the matter was listed on 20 August 2024. No stay was granted.

    Later development: the State and Commission withdrew these petitions on 14 July 2026.

  4. Calcutta High Court: universities warned over admissions to struck-down classes

    In WPA(P) 430 of 2024, the Division Bench (Rajasekhar Mantha and Tapabrata Chakraborty, JJ.) found that universities were still admitting students under reservations for the classes struck down on 22 May 2024, with no Supreme Court stay in place. It took the prima facie view that universities may have to compensate each affected student at least Rs 5 lakh. Interim order; listed for 7 October 2024.

  5. Calcutta High Court: no stay of the 2013 admissions Act; orders sent to all universities

    In the same PIL, the Division Bench declined to stay the 2013 admissions reservation Act and directed that its orders be circulated to all universities and examination bodies in the State.

  6. Supreme Court: SLP(C) 17751–17755 of 2024

    State of West Bengal & Anr. v. Amal Chandra Das. The bundled official Supreme Court record of proceedings arises from the 22 May 2024 High Court judgment. Use it with the Supreme Court case-status service for the current listing and later orders.

  7. Supreme Court: hearing on the State appeals; detailed arguments fixed for January

    In SLP(C) 17751–17755 of 2024 and connected appeals the Court observed during the hearing that reservation cannot be based on religion, while the State argued that its classification rested on backwardness. Detailed arguments were fixed for 7 January 2025. The written order itself only lists the matters for that date; the remarks come from the PTI report.

  8. Supreme Court: broader connected-appeal cluster listed for final hearing

    The official record groups the State’s main appeal with proceedings involving Tuhina Parvin (Diary 30078/2024), Md. Nawsad Siddique (Diary 31942/2024), Sk. Serafuddin (Diary 31944/2024), Aatmadeep (SLP(C) 16936/2024), Mustafijur Rahaman (SLP(C) 18931–18935/2024), Bengal Madrasah Education Forum (SLP(C) 18926–18930/2024), West Bengal Commission for Backward Classes (Diary 36073/2024), Md. Taiedul Islam (SLP(C) 20849/2024), and Md. Najmul Hoque (SLP(C) 29017–29021/2024). By consent, the Court listed the matters for final hearing on 28 January 2025. The official 5 May 2026 cause list still identifies this connected cluster; this evidence does not establish a final merits disposal.

    Later development: see the 14 July 2026 withdrawal order and 1 October 2026 fresh proceedings below. Earlier listings and stays do not establish the current position.

  9. Calcutta High Court: Aatmadeep PIL and Amal Chandra Das PIL listed together

    In WPA(P) 387/2024 (Aatmadeep) with WPA(P) 430/2024 (Amal Chandra Das), the Court recorded a State affidavit about implementation of the 22 May 2024 judgment and allegations that recruitment/admission bodies continued to use the struck-down OBC-A/OBC-B categories. The Court did not determine the merits in this order; it listed the matters for further consideration.

  10. Supreme Court: State says the Commission is redoing the OBC exercise; matter posted to July

    Before Justices B.R. Gavai and A.G. Masih in SLP(C) 17751–17755 of 2024, the State said the West Bengal Commission for Backward Classes was conducting a fresh exercise to identify backward classes, expected to take about three months. The matter was posted to July 2025 without prejudice to either side.

  11. Calcutta High Court: interim directions on the Commission's benchmark survey

    In WPA(P) 111, 119 and 132 of 2025, the Division Bench was not prima facie satisfied with the Backward Classes Commission's process for the new survey. It directed wide publicity in Bengali and local-language newspapers, asked District Magistrates and BDOs to help classes apply, called for the Commission's compliance affidavit by 19 June 2025, and added the NCBC as a respondent.

  12. Calcutta High Court: WBJEE PG admission implementation order

    In WPA 9132/2025, Supriya Mondal & Ors. v. State of West Bengal & Ors., concerning JEMAS PG 2024–25 admissions, the Court directed the Joint Entrance Board to identify candidates among the 66 pre-2010 classes, recast the panel at 7% OBC reservation, and complete the specified admission steps. The State appealed this order in MAT 943 and 955 of 2025, which are separate cases; on 2 July 2025 the appeal bench sent them to the Chief Justice.

  13. Calcutta High Court: challenge to the 2025 benchmark-survey process

    The order in WPA(P) 111, 119 and 132 of 2025, with WPA(P) 430 of 2024, records challenges to the benchmark survey, the 28 February 2025 Commission memo, the 1 March 2025 district communication, and the 8 and 27 May 2025 notifications.

    Later development: see the 14 July 2026 withdrawal order and 1 October 2026 fresh proceedings below. Earlier listings and stays do not establish the current position.

  14. Calcutta High Court: JEMAS PG appeals referred on the meaning of "already availed"

    In MAT 943 and 955 of 2025 (State v. Supriya Mondal), the Division Bench placed the State's appeals before the Chief Justice so that the Bench which decided Amal Chandra Das could clarify what "already availed the benefit of reservation" means.

  15. Supreme Court: later 2025 appeal record

    SLP(C) 17528/2025, State of West Bengal v. Amal Chandra Das & Ors. The bundled official office report identifies the related 17 June 2025 High Court order. It is a procedural record, not a merits judgment.

  16. Supreme Court: stay of the 17 June 2025 High Court order

    In SLP(C) 17422/2025, 17528/2025 and 17973–17974/2025, the Supreme Court issued notice and recorded an interim stay of the 17 June 2025 High Court judgment and order. This is an interim procedural development, not a final disposal of the underlying issues.

    Later development: see the 14 July 2026 withdrawal order and 1 October 2026 fresh proceedings below. Earlier listings and stays do not establish the current position.

  17. Calcutta High Court: JEMAS PG contempt proceedings

    The order in CPAN 1362 and 1365 of 2025 records contempt proceedings linked to implementation of the 22 May 2024 judgment and the 21 May 2025 WPA 9132 court-text mirror print. It describes the proceedings and related pending appeals; it should be read for its own operative directions and procedural setting.

  18. Calcutta High Court: fresh WBJEE 2025 merit list ordered on the pre-2010 basis

    Justice Kausik Chanda, acting on candidates’ complaints, held that the WBJEE 2025 merit list breached the 21 May 2025 order by applying the 10 June 2025 reservation policy. He directed a fresh list within 15 days with 7% reservation for the 66 pre-2010 classes. The Supreme Court stayed this direction on 22 August 2025 (Diary 45628 of 2025).

  19. Supreme Court: interim stay in the JEMAS PG contempt appeal

    In Diary Nos. 45526/2025 and 45628/2025, arising from the 7 August 2025 Calcutta High Court order in CPAN 1362/2025, the Supreme Court issued notice, stayed the impugned order until further orders, and tagged the matters with SLP(C) 17422/2025. This is an interim procedural order, not a decision on the underlying OBC issues.

    Later development: see the 14 July 2026 withdrawal order and 1 October 2026 fresh proceedings below. Earlier listings and stays do not establish the current position.

  20. Supreme Court: State appeals listed for 6 November 2025

    A bench of the Chief Justice and K. Vinod Chandran, J. listed SLP(C) 17751–17755 of 2024 and the connected matters for 6 November 2025. This confirms the hearing date of the 6 November 2025 order reported by Scroll.

  21. Supreme Court: High Court not to go ahead with the hearing until further orders

    Before the Chief Justice, K. Vinod Chandran and Vipul M. Pancholi JJ., in the State's appeals (SLP(C) 17751–17755/2024 and the connected petitions), the Court directed listing after four weeks and clarified that until further orders the High Court would not proceed further with the hearing of the petitions. The order does not name the High Court matters; Scroll reported on 7 November 2025 that they were the cases on the fresh OBC list.

    Later development: the State and Commission withdrew these petitions on 14 July 2026.

  22. Calcutta High Court: voided OBC certificates and the electoral roll revision

    On a voter’s petition (Arijit Bakshi), Justice Krishna Rao directed the Chief Electoral Officer to decide within a week whether OBC certificates struck down by the Court could be accepted in the Special Intensive Revision. The CEO then told district officers not to accept them.

  23. Supreme Court: connected OBC SLPs listed with applications to vacate stay

    An official office report for SLP(C) 17422, 17528 and 17973–17974 of 2025 records that the matters were listed with applications for clarification/direction and for vacation of the interim stay. It also records incomplete service on specified respondents. The official 5 May 2026 cause list again lists the vacation applications. Neither record is a disposal order, and neither should be used to infer what happened in the later July withdrawal proceedings.

    Later development: see the 14 July 2026 withdrawal order and 1 October 2026 fresh proceedings below. Earlier listings and stays do not establish the current position.

  24. Calcutta High Court: first hearing of the PIL against the 18 May 2026 notifications

    In WPA(P) 305/2026 (Right and Justice Foundation), the Division Bench (Partha Sarathi Chatterjee J. and Tapabrata Chakraborty A.C.J.) heard the petitioners, asked the Advocate General to take instructions and listed the PIL on 2 July 2026. It gave no direction on the notifications.

    Later development: the PIL was not entertained on 3 July 2026.

  25. Calcutta High Court: recruitment-category challenges after the 2026 reset

    Orders in WPA 14695/2026 (Bistriti Parveen) and WPA 14698/2026 (Yasin Chowdhury) concern candidates who had applied as OBC-A candidates before the 18 May 2026 notifications. The Court directed an extension of the application-editing date while listing the matters for further hearing; the orders do not finally determine the merits.

  26. Calcutta High Court: PIL challenging the 18 May 2026 notifications

    In WPA(P) 305/2026, Right and Justice Foundation & Anr. v. State of West Bengal & Ors., the PIL challenged Notifications 944 and 945 and Letter 946. The Division Bench declined to entertain the PIL, recording that the Supreme Court was already seized of the principal issues and that the State’s 18 May 2026 decision should be placed before the Supreme Court in the pending SLP.

    Later development: see the 14 July 2026 withdrawal order and 1 October 2026 fresh proceedings below. Earlier listings and stays do not establish the current position.

  27. Calcutta High Court: single-judge challenge to the 18 May 2026 notifications dismissed

    In WPA 15380 of 2026 (Mahamadul Hasan Gayen), Justice Krishna Rao dismissed a challenge to the 18 May 2026 notifications, holding that a single judge could not revisit them after the Division Bench declined the PIL on 3 July 2026 because the Supreme Court was seized of the issue.

  28. Calcutta High Court: second PIL against the 18 May 2026 notifications; State asked to appear

    Mijanul Kabir and another, in WPA(P) 319/2026, ask the Court to quash Notifications 944 and 945 and Letter 946 of 18 May 2026 and to restore the 2025 notifications for the 74 affected communities. The State was unrepresented despite service, so the Division Bench (Partha Sarathi Chatterjee J. and Tapabrata Chakraborty A.C.J.) asked the Additional Government Pleader to appear for it, directed the petitioners to give him a copy of the petition within a week, and listed the matter on 16 July 2026.

  29. Calcutta High Court: Bistriti Parveen petition withdrawn

    In WPA 14695/2026, Bistriti Parveen v. State of West Bengal & Ors., the petitioner stated that she had exercised the option available under the challenged 12 June 2026 notification and sought permission to withdraw. The Court dismissed the writ petition as withdrawn with liberty to file afresh, vacated any interim order, and disposed of connected applications. This is a procedural closure of that petition, not a merits ruling on the OBC classification issues.

  30. Calcutta High Court: Yasin Chowdhury's OBC-A application protected pending the Supreme Court

    In WPA 14698 of 2026, Justice Bivas Pattanayak directed the College Service Commission not to cancel the petitioner's OBC-A application or move him to the General category until the Supreme Court decides the pending matters. The order is limited to the petitioner.

  31. Supreme Court: State and Commission petitions dismissed as withdrawn

    The Court permitted withdrawal of the State’s listed 2024 and 2025 SLPs and expressly included Diary 45526/2025, SLP(C) 26497/2025 and the Commission’s Diary 36073/2024. Other affected persons remain free to approach the Court. This closes the specified petitions without a merits ruling; it does not dispose of every connected party’s appeal. Read the August judgment for its account of the effect on the July 2025 stay.

  32. Calcutta High Court: Mijanul Kabir PIL to be decided on affidavits; maintainability left open

    In WPA(P) 319/2026 the Division Bench (Rajasekhar Mantha J. and Tapabrata Chakraborty A.C.J.) held that the matter needs affidavits: the State has six weeks to file its opposition and the petitioners four weeks after that to reply. The Bench said it was not fully satisfied that the PIL is maintainable and left that question for the final hearing. No interim order was passed on the notifications.

    Status: pending. No later order is in the archive.

  33. Calcutta High Court: Shreyasi Dhang certificate-validity judgment

    In Shreyasi Dhang, the Division Bench rejected the admission-related appeal and held the May–June 2025 re-declaration unlawful. Paragraph 25 treats certificates issued during 8 May–12 June 2025 and 10 June 2025–18 May 2026 as void from inception and requires fresh certification for eligible pre-2010 classes. The judgment records that withdrawal of the State’s SLPs extinguished the interim stay and revived the High Court order. It must now be read with the fresh Supreme Court proceedings of 1 October. The mirror contains inconsistent historical dates for the 2025 orders; the archived orders establish 17 June and 28 July 2025.

  34. Calcutta High Court: NEET-UG 2026 candidates cannot switch to EWS after results

    In WPA 21501 of 2026 (Hasibur Rahaman Mondal & Ors.), Justice Amrita Sinha dismissed a petition by eight candidates who had applied as General or OBC-NCL and later sought EWS counselling. The Court held that a valid EWS certificate was needed on the application date. Judgment dated 14 August 2026 (2026:CHC-AS:1271).

  35. Calcutta High Court: Division Bench upholds the NEET-UG EWS ruling

    In MAT 1374 of 2026, the Division Bench dismissed the appeal against the 14 August 2026 judgment, confirming that NEET-UG 2026 candidates who applied as General or OBC cannot switch to EWS at counselling.

  36. Calcutta High Court: re-verification of all caste certificates since 2011 stayed

    In two PILs, WPA(P) 275/2026 (Dr. Md. Adil Hossain) and WPA(P) 300/2026 (CPI(ML) Liberation, West Bengal State Committee), the Division Bench (Atarup Banerjee J. and Tapabrata Chakraborty A.C.J.) stayed the BCW Department's memo of 14 May 2026 until the PILs are decided. That memo asked every Sub-Divisional Officer to re-verify all caste certificates issued since 2011 and warned of personal liability for laxity. The Bench found a prima facie case that the certificate-issuing authorities were being told what to do by a superior officer, and that the memo appeared to create a fresh ground for cancelling certificates. The State has four weeks to file affidavits and the petitioners two weeks to reply. Officers can still act case by case under the 1994 Act and 1995 Rules.

    Status: pending; the stay continues until the PILs are decided.

  37. Calcutta High Court: SLST 2025 candidates cannot claim the struck-down OBC-A category

    In WPA 23207 of 2026 with WPA 23209 of 2026 (Mehebuba Khatun & Ors.), Justice Aniruddha Roy dismissed petitions by Second SLST 2025 candidates seeking OBC-A reserved status, holding that the Amal Chandra Das judgment had become final before recruitment began and that a place on the merit panel gave no vested right. Judgment dated 31 August 2026 (2026:CHC-AS:1414); reported 7 September 2026.

  38. Calcutta High Court: SLST EWS appeal; School Service Commission asked about the BCW letter of 10 August 2026

    In FMA 1002/2026, 2nd SLST 2025 candidates who received EWS certificates after the application deadline appealed against a single-judge ruling that they were ineligible. They relied on a BCW Department letter of 10 August 2026 saying such candidates could be treated as EWS if the certificate is for the year the SLST notice was published. The Division Bench (Rajasekhar Mantha and Anuj Singh JJ.) noted the appeal would become academic if the School Service Commission accepted that letter, asked the Commission's counsel to take instructions, and listed the appeal on 14 September 2026.

    Later development: the appeal was allowed on 14 September 2026.

  39. Calcutta High Court: SLST candidates to be considered as EWS after verification

    In FMA 1002 of 2026 (Mir Mazharul Islam), the Division Bench (Rajasekhar Mantha and Anuj Singh, JJ.) set aside the single-judge order of 24 March 2026 in WPA 5700 of 2026. The appellants, second SLST candidates, are to be treated as EWS once the SLST verifies their certificates.

  40. Calcutta High Court: review of the SLST EWS judgment refused

    In RVW 239 and 241 of 2026 (Arindam Saha), the Division Bench dismissed applications seeking review of the 14 September 2026 judgment in FMA 1002 of 2026.

  41. Supreme Court: fresh challenges; appointments subject to outcome

    In Right and Justice Foundation and the connected petition, the Court issued notice, allowed intervention/impleadment and directed tagging with Diary 54999/2026. Appointments must follow the eventual SLP result, with that condition included in appointment letters. It allowed four weeks for counters and two more for rejoinders, and directed listing on 23 November 2026. The order grants no general stay of the August judgment and does not restore 17% reservation. The listing date is a future direction as of the 4 November review, not a completed hearing.

  42. Supreme Court: NEET-UG EWS claim closed; benefit available next year

    In SLP(C) 31121 of 2026, a bench of P.S. Narasimha and Alok Aradhe, JJ. disposed of the appeal from MAT 1374 of 2026. EWS certificates obtained after the NEET-UG result could not be used for counselling by candidates who had applied as General or OBC; the Court said the EWS benefit would be available to them next year.

  43. Calcutta High Court: Nilanjona Kundu category-update representations

    For 2nd SLST candidates claiming membership of retained OBC classes, the Court permitted representations to the Commission by 15 October with earlier certificates, the 2025 update and current category details. The Commission must verify eligibility and decide within ten working days after reopening following Laxmi Puja. The petition was disposed of; the order expressly creates no automatic right to reservation. This was relief for the petitioners, not a general reopening of the editing window. The representation deadline has passed.

  44. Calcutta High Court: already-selected OBC-A candidates outside the 7 August 2026 notification

    In WPA 26656 of 2026 (Aslam Hossain), Justice Reetobroto Kumar Mitra held that petitioners recommended as OBC-A for Laboratory Assistant posts had already availed the reservation, so the 7 August 2026 notification did not affect them. The Court refused to stay the notification and directed the State to expedite their medical examination.

  45. Calcutta High Court: new OBC roster in a selection already underway questioned

    In APOT 136 of 2026 (Shamim Akhtar), a bench of Chief Justice Ravindra V. Ghuge and Om Narayan Rai, J. said that applying the new reservation policy from the second phase of a selection already underway was "a matter of circumspection", and listed the appeal for 13 November 2026. No ruling yet.

  46. Calcutta High Court: Abeda Khatoon retained-class candidates

    The Court permitted the petitioners, described as untainted in-service 2nd SLST candidates from retained OBC classes, to make representations by 22 October. It required verification of their certificates and prior updates and consideration of their position under Bibek Paria. The writ was disposed of with no automatic entitlement to reservation. This concerns a missed category update within retained classes; it does not reintroduce excluded classes or protect every certificate. The representation deadline has passed.

  47. Calcutta High Court: candidates dropped from the OBC list may compete as EWS in police recruitment

    In WPA 28984 of 2026 (Srikanta Chakraborty), Justice Reetobroto Kumar Mitra dismissed a challenge to allowing candidates removed from the OBC list to compete as EWS in the 2024 Kolkata Police constable recruitment, holding that the petitioners had taken part without protest. The judgment was modified on 22 October 2026.

  48. Calcutta High Court: category-update window is not a fresh application window

    In WPA 31497 of 2026 (Sambhu Charan Bera), Justice Rishad Medora held that the 14 October 2026 notice only lets existing OBC-A and OBC-B applicants correct their category in the primary-teacher recruitment, and does not allow new applications.

  49. Calcutta High Court: Mohabul Islam OBC-to-EWS claim requires affidavits

    Former OBC-A/OBC-B primary-teacher applicants who later obtained EWS certificates challenged the refusal to accept an EWS category update. The Court called for opposition affidavits within three weeks after Puja Vacation and replies within one week thereafter, with listing before the Regular Bench after that period. All intervening steps are subject to the writ’s result. It has not decided an entitlement to EWS conversion or ordered a general extension of the Board’s editing window.

Litigation support note · not an official order

Legal principles for existing OBC-certificate appointees

A user-supplied bilingual note argues that bona fide employees appointed on government-issued and verified OBC certificates should not face blanket termination merely because a reservation policy or class-list process is later invalidated. Treat this as an argument map: verify every citation against the actual judgment before using it.

Factual premise

No fraud or false claim

The note’s protection argument depends on the employee having acted in good faith, without misrepresentation, and on certificates having been issued and verified by competent government authorities before appointment.

Service finality

Completed appointments

It distinguishes policy validity from appointment validity and says completed recruitment, seniority, promotion, pension, vested rights, and livelihood interests require individualised treatment.

Process safeguard

No blanket cancellation

The note relies on Articles 14, 16, and 21, natural justice, proportionality, legitimate expectation, and administrative fairness to oppose mass termination without hearing.

Use discipline: this note is useful for framing questions in employee-protection litigation, but it is not a substitute for the operative order in the pending West Bengal OBC matters. It should be read with the fraud exception in Vishwanatha Pillai and Jagdish Balaram Bahira, and with actual court orders, pleadings, and verified SCC/official judgment links before treating any principle as controlling.
RecordForumIssue trackedArchived evidenceStatus discipline
WPO 60/2011 and connected mattersCalcutta High CourtValidity/process of OBC-list and reservation actionsBundled judgment copyRead the operative portion; verify with court record.
SLP(C) 17751–17755/2024Supreme Court of IndiaState appeal from the 22 May 2024 judgment14 Jul 2026 withdrawal order (court-text mirror)Dismissed as withdrawn; no merits ruling. Other affected persons may approach the Court.
Connected 2024 SLPs/diariesSupreme Court of IndiaSeparate party appeals and interventions7 Jan 2025 record; 14 Jul 2026 withdrawal orderDo not infer disposal of every party appeal. Diary 36073/2024 is expressly withdrawn; unnamed proceedings need separate checks.
WPA(P) 387/2024 & 430/2024Calcutta High CourtImplementation of the 2024 judgment in recruitment/admission processes21 Jan 2025 court-text mirrorListed for further consideration; not a merits disposal.
WPA 9132/2025; MAT 943 & 955/2025Calcutta High CourtJEMAS PG 2024–25 OBC reservation and merit-list implementation21 May 2025 court-text mirror; 7 Aug 2025 bundled follow-upThe 21 May order was disposed of; later appeal status must be checked separately.
2025 benchmark-survey challengeCalcutta High CourtSurvey process and 2025 notifications17 Jun 2025 order; 12 Aug 2026 judgmentThe August judgment records revival of the High Court order after withdrawal of the State’s SLPs. See fresh October proceedings.
SLP(C) 17422, 17528, 17973–17974/2025; Diary 45526 & 45628/2025Supreme Court of India2025 notifications and JEMAS PG contempt appeals14 Jul 2026 withdrawal order (court-text mirror)Specified 2025 SLPs and Diary 45526/2025 withdrawn; SLP(C) 26497/2025 is also named. Check Diary 45628/2025 independently; tagging alone does not prove its disposal.
WPA 14695 & 14698/2026Calcutta High CourtRecruitment impact of the 18 May 2026 notification resetBundled 1 Jul orders and 8 Jul withdrawal order in WPA 14695WPA 14695 was withdrawn with liberty to file afresh; WPA 14698 requires a separate current-status check.
WPA(P) 305/2026Calcutta High Court / Supreme CourtNotifications 944/945 and Letter 9463 Jul High Court order; 1 Oct Supreme Court orderPIL dismissed; fresh challenge in Diary 41300/2026 received notice on 1 October.
MAT 1320/2026Calcutta High CourtCertificate validity / admissions12 Aug 2026 Shreyasi Dhang judgment (mirror)Appeal disposed of; read with fresh Supreme Court challenges.
Diary 41300 & 50605/2026; tagged Diary 54999/2026Supreme Court of IndiaFresh challenges after the State’s withdrawal1 Oct 2026 order (mirror)Notice issued; appointments subject to outcome. Directed listing: 23 Nov 2026. No general stay recorded.
WPA 29788 & 30672/2026Calcutta High CourtRetained-class SLST applicants who missed updates13 & 15 Oct 2026 orders (mirrors)Petitions disposed of with representation/verification directions; no automatic reservation entitlement.
WPA 31572/2026Calcutta High CourtFormer OBC applicants seeking EWS category update31 Oct 2026 order (mirror)Affidavits called for; intervening steps subject to result. EWS entitlement remains undecided.
Source discipline: the archive includes key 2025–26 orders, but the large Supreme Court filing bundles remain catalogued rather than published. Add later certified/official orders, then map each order to the exact notification, survey memo, recruitment process, or admission process affected.