Hearings & gaps · Public notices and audit

Completeness Audit

Review the Jana Shunani notice table, missing records, original-source links, and procedural gaps behind the notification trail.

134Archived source PDFs
66Classes in Notification 945
7%Reservation in the May 2026 notice
5Evidence gaps tracked

The archive contains the core 2010, 2025, and 2026 notifications, a substantial public-hearing notice set, and the court orders in the cases that followed. The remaining procedural gap is the West Bengal Commission for Backward Classes record behind the notices: benchmark-survey memos, class-wise advice reports, and survey data.

Found online from original sources

Official BCW order indexes, official WBCBC public-hearing notice list, and the official 2025 notification-wise OBC list.

Partly found

Benchmark-survey memos are quoted or mirrored online, but the original Commission PDF locations still need recovery or download from the department/Commission if available.

Not yet archived

Class-wise Commission advice and survey reports, the benchmark-survey memo trail, the Supreme Court order of 6 November 2025, later orders in the implementation PILs (none found after January 2025) and in the JEMAS PG appeals (none found after August 2025), and original source pages for hearing notices held only as archived scans.

Public Hearings / Jana Shunani

The published hearing archive supplies a fuller Jana Shunani run from 29 April through 24 May 2025. The notices use Adivasi Bhavan, Premises No. 2221, Action Area 3A, Rajarhat, New Town, Kolkata-700160 as venue; visually read notices and text-extracted Bengali advertisements are listed below with source links.

Date Time Classes / communities named in notice Official advertisement
29 Apr 202512:00Sekh; Mallick; Molla; Khan (Muslim); Bhatia (Muslim)Open PDF
30 Apr 202512:00Bosni; Gurung; Khas; Midde; Mandal (Muslim)Open PDF
2 May 20254:00Kaji; Tutia; Bhangi (Muslim)Open PDF
3 May 202512:00Bairagi/Baishnab; Laskar (Muslim); Jamadar (Muslim); Haldar (Muslim)Open PDF
4 May 202512:00Khotta; Gazi; Muslim BiswasOpen PDF
13 May 202512:00Dalal (Muslim); Baidya (Muslim); Rajmistri; Chasatti/ChasaOpen PDF
14 May 20254:00Gayen (Muslim); Piyada/Peyada (Muslim); Dhali (Muslim); Malithya (Muslim)Open PDF
15 May 202512:00Shah; Ostagar/Darji (Muslim); Purkait (Muslim); Tarafdar (Muslim); Dafadar (Muslim); Sardar (Muslim)Open PDF
16 May 202512:00Sarkar (Muslim); Mistri (Muslim); Gharami (Muslim); Muslim Sanpui/Sapui; Akunji/Akan/Akhan (Muslim); Paik (Muslim)Open PDF
18 May 202512:00Kan (Muslim); Mahaldar (Muslim); Goldar (Muslim); Chutor Mistri (Muslim); Dewan (Muslim)Open PDF
19 May 202512:00Bayen (Muslim); Khondekar/Khonkar (Muslim); Halsana (Muslim); Mal Muslim; Sepai (Muslim); Abdal (Muslim)Open PDF
20 May 202512:00Kayal (Muslim); Kalwar; Naiya (Muslim); Beldar Muslim; Muslim Penchi; Bhuiya/Bhunya (Muslim)Open PDF
21 May 20254:00Nikari (Muslim); Daptari (Muslim); Muslim Barujibi/Barui; Bepari/Byapari MuslimOpen PDF
22 May 202512:00Hazari (Muslim); Muchi/Chamar Muslim; Pailan (Muslim); Chowdhury/Chowdhuri (Muslim); Muslim Mali/Faraji (Muslim); SadgopeOpen PDF
23 May 202512:00Majhi; Siuli (Muslim); Shikari (Muslim); Mukti/Mufti (Muslim); Dhukre (Muslim)Open PDF
24 May 202512:00Layek (Muslim); Khansama; Dhabak (Muslim); Nepali BrahminOpen PDF

New Sources Checked

Source What it adds Use in final dataset
Not archived OBC ANALYSIS REPORT WITH NOTIFICATION.xlsx Six sheets: 66 pre-2010 classes; old OBC list; 2025 new list; notification plus hearing dates; classes struck down by High Court; A/B movement analysis. Strong structured source. It records 66 pre-2010 entries, 114 struck-down/affected entries, and a 2025 comparison table.
Document needed for Cast certificate Issue Certificate-issuance procedure documents, including amended OBC certificate, document verification, Aadhaar/local residence proof, Kolkata hearing authority, and updated OBC certificate guidelines. Administrative/certificate layer. Useful for showing how certificates are issued/revalidated, not for deciding which class is OBC.
BCW department orders and Notification Acts, rules, roster/register orders, SC/ST identification law, EWS guidelines, and WBCBC constitution/administrative orders. Legal/admin background layer. Important for context, but only selected PDFs are directly OBC-list relevant.
PRD orders Excel: "Backward" search Four matching rows: 2663, 2896, 3276, and 3804 on Backward Class panchayat survey work. The same PDF folder also supplied the missing first guideline, 2572/PN/O/1/1S-5/2012 dated 25 Apr 2012. Strong procedural evidence layer for caste/class population enumeration: survey rationale, GP-constituency units, Census/SECC reference records, draft publication, claims/objections, final publication, and software compilation.
What to add Why it matters Original / best source link
BCW official 2025 order index Confirms the official publication entries for 917, 1056, 1057, 1106, 1107, the 2025 model roster, and related downloads. Backward Classes Welfare Department orders page
BCW official 2026 order index Confirms official publication of 944-BCW and 945-BCW dated 18 May 2026. Backward Classes Welfare Department orders page
Notification-wise OBC list up to 03 Jun 2025 This is the missing full 2025 data table: it links communities to approval memo numbers and notifications before the 2026 withdrawal. Bundled official PDF Fetched from BCW
WBCBC public notice for inclusion The Commission's invitation, issued after the High Court's 6 May 2025 order in WPA(P) 111/2025, for communities not on the SC, ST or OBC lists to apply for inclusion. It came after the hearings had begun on 29 April. English public notice | 6 May 2025 order | Bengali public notice
Public hearing notices, 29 Apr to 4 May 2025 These are part of the "jana shunani" trail before the 2025 recommendations.
Public hearing notices, 13 May to 24 May 2025 These complete the visible WBCBC public-hearing chain that is not yet fully represented in the archive.
Benchmark Survey memo dated 28 Feb 2025 and Nadia memo dated 1 Mar 2025 These are the survey-start documents challenged in later litigation. They are not yet in the archive. Original file not yet located. The 17 Jun 2025 High Court order records the 28 Feb Commission memo and 1 Mar District Welfare Officer communication; secondary mirrors reproduce the Nadia memo text.
Class-wise WBCBC advice / recommendation reports for the 2025 inclusions The 2025 notifications say the Commission relied on detailed surveys, public hearings, and reasoned opinions. Those reports are the strongest missing evidentiary layer. Add if supplied by WBCBC/BCW Department, RTI response, or court record annexures.
Raw or tabulated benchmark survey data Needed to test whether each community’s social, educational, and economic backwardness findings match the notified outcome. Add district/block survey tables if obtained from the Commission, district offices, or litigation annexures.
WBCBC No. 390-Estt./WBCBC dated 26 May 2025 Requests benchmark survey for seven communities: Mahishya, Baishya Saha, Kayastha, Samudra Banik, Deswali Majhi, Beniya/Gandha Banik, and Ekadash Tili. Original file not yet located on the WBCBC home page. Mirror/source text found at Manuals+ copy.
Standalone Gazette page for Corrigendum No. 1172-BCW/MR-38/2025 Covered inside the bundled 1107 PDF, but a standalone copy may be useful for citation hygiene. Official BCW download for 1107 includes the corrigendum page; keep as optional, not a blocking gap.
17 Jun 2025 High Court interim order Important legal update after the 2025 notification set: the order discusses the benchmark survey challenge, 113 sub-castes, and the 2025 notifications. Order text on Indian Kanoon
22 May 2024 High Court judgment The judgment is the legal hinge for the 2025 re-survey/sub-categorisation effort and the 2026 reset. Judgment text on Indian Kanoon | PDF copy